Celebrating Food! Celebrating Life!

Mrs Ng SK’s Butter Cake… an Échiré Extravaganza

DSC_1782 s
“Nostalgia” is a word which I find myself using and abusing quite frequently of late. More often than I’d hoped to, I find myself taking long walks down the memory lane (such a cliché I know!) time and time again, revisiting the sights and smells of yesteryears quite literally, through the numerous bakes and makes which I’d undertaken over the last year or so. Memory is such a powerful tool, using one’s not-too-distant past to fuel one’s present and possibly the future, more often than others, in a reflective and contemplative mode, a tell-tale sign of age and hopefully wisdom. After all, collective memories of a concerted groups is the basic foundation of “heritage”.

Alas many of these flavours and smells have become a thing of the past. Changing palates and tastebuds, more generous offering of options and choice, an almost deliberately played out sense of propriety towards being more health conscious, are just some of the proponents and culprits which led to the “extinction” of many of the “childhood” flavours.

DSC_1778 s
Truth be told, when Wendy from Table for 2 or more posted a recipe of a butter cake shared by a fellow church mate from her hometown, I was quick to dismiss it as a rather rustic-looking, and probably run-in-the mill buttercake, like many of its predecessors over Google. It was raved  as being soft and fluffy and most important of all, crack-free, but I remained unfaltered. It was only when more praise of it poured in from all over the baking bloggers’ circle when I’d realised how “significant” this cake is to many folks out there. Its certainly not just about how fuss-free it looked or how buttery it tasted, but the sense of nostalgia which was invoked in those who tried it. To them, it was a flavour of the past coming to life again and that most certainly struck a chord in me and got me very curious.
DSC_1682 s
It is a rather no-frills butter cake using the “chiffon method”, where the whites and yolks were first separated. The whites are whisked into a meringue while the yolks worked into a batter concoction, with the final reunion of the two, when the meringue is evntually folded into the egg-flour-butter batter. Slightly more laborious than to beat in everything together in quick successions but the results yielded in terms of texture more than make up for the extra effort required.

I don’t have an 8″ square cake tin, so the recipe is “upsized” for a 9″ square one. And since its a butter cake, I’d decided to “upscale” it as well and used French beurre d’Échiré for a wholesome “Echire Extravanganza”! And to match, I’d used vanilla seeds-loaded extract from Eurovanille and 蒙牛 Monmilk from Inner Mongolia!
DSC_1698 s

Mrs Ng SK’s Vanilla Butter Cake , adapted from Wendy of Table for 2 or more 


for butter batter
300g salted butter, softened slightly
5 egg yolks of grade B eggs (each egg appro. 52-55g)
150g castor sugar
260g self raising flour, sifted***
80g milk
2 tsp vanilla extract
for meringue
5 egg whites of grade B eggs (each egg appro. 52-55g)
70g castor sugar
1/2 tsp cream of tartar (mixed thoroughly with sugar)
DSC_1708 s

1. Preheat oven at 170C. Prepare a 9″square pan by lining the base and grease the sides thoroughly
2. Separate the eggs, and place the whites into a clean and dry mixing bowl. Beat egg whites until foamy and gradually pour in sugar+tartar mixture in 2-3 additions and beat until stiff peaks. Set aside.
3. Using the same mixer, cream butter with sugar until pale and fluffy and add vanilla extract and mix thoroughly. Put in egg yolks one by one and beat well after each addition.
4. Add half the flour and mix on low speed until incorporated. Add milk in 2 additions and mix until well incorporated. Mix in remaining flour.
5. Scoop half of the meringue in (2) into cake batter in (4) and mix on low speed. FOLD in remaining meringue until just incorporated.
6. Pour batter into greased pan and level.
7. Place cake pan in preheated oven and bake for 20 minutes. Reduce heat to 150C and continue to bake for 25 min
8. Test that skewer comes out clean and leave the cake in the oven with door slightly ajar for 10 min.
9. Remove cake from oven. Invert cake onto a cooling rack until completely cooled down.

*** I did not have self-raising flour at home, so I made some on my own, basically by mixing plain flour with baking powder in the ratio of 1 tsp of baking powder for every 3/4 cup of plain flour. The dry ingredients were sifted numerous times to ensure that the baking powder is thoroughly mixed with the plain flour. Traditionally, self-raising flour substitute recipes calls for salt to be added as well, but I’d omitted it since this recipe uses salted butter. The salt from the butter should provide sufficient unami to the cake on its own!
DSC_1705 s

Weighing the egg yolks and whites separately and yet together to make sure I get them in the right proportions…
The method of preparation I’d adopted is slightly different from Wendy’s. Whilst she whipped her cake batter and meringue simultaneously with her KA and hand mixer at the same time, I’d chosen to work on the meringue first and use the same pair of beaters on my hand blender to cream the butter and prepare the batter componenent subsequently. I was too lazy to lug out my KW mixer from storage and preparing the meringue first saves me the hassle of washing the mixer beaters. Hence, to further stabilise the meringue, I’d added half a teaspoon of cream of tartar. This method works well for me for cakes that requires the chiffon aka egg separation method.

DSC_1714 s
But there is one thing one needs to note about this method, i.e. while the acidity of cream of tartar stabilises the meringue, enabling it to hold its shape for a much longer time, it would invariably activate the baking powder, which is essentially sodium bicarbonate, somewhat prematurely, once the meringue has been incorporated into the cake batter. So one has to work reasonably fast to prevent losing too much of the carbon dioxide which provides the cake the necessary lift for all the much-desired soft and fluffy textures it imbues.
DSC_1710 s
As with all good butter cakes, the choice of butter is of crucial pertinence. This almost sounded like an oxymoron and somewhat anal retentive I know but this couldn’t be more emphasised. In fact, I was “prompted” into using Echire butter when I saw Ivy, a fellow homebaker used it for her Mrs Ng SK’s Vanilla and Butter Cake. I was elated to know someone else who ‘d tried and appreciated the finer qualities of this wonderful butter whilst others would probably have merely shuddered and convulsed after a look at its price tag. I guess the chinese saying of 一分钱一分货 holds true here, which is of loose equivalence to the proverbial “you pay peanuts, you get monkeys”. When asked where she got the idea from, she said it all started from me “endorsing the butter” on this blog! Glad to have been the source of inspiration! I’d used Echire “demi-sel” for the cake as Wendy called for the use of salted butter in this cake. So in went all 300g of good butter! As I’d only had 1 tub (250g) of Echire demi sel at home, I’d topped up the remaining 50g with the Doux unsalted one. On the whole, I still found the savouriness too overtly expressed in the finished cake, when I would have preferred it to be slightly more subtle, lending just sufficient “unami-ness” to the flavour profile but not overpowering. I would use all Doux butter for future bakes, with probably a 1/4 tsp of fleur de sel added. 🙂
DSC_1797 s
On the whole, I really love this buttercake. The flavours are indeed very rustic and simple, conjuring images of the buttercakes from neighbourhood confectioneries which I’d enjoyed as a boy. It sent me straight back to my childhood and I would most certainly make this cake in the years to come, not only to enjoy all its rich buttery flavours, but also to re-live all those childhood memories over and over again.
DSC_1809 s

31 responses

  1. m.

    hi where did you get your beurre d’Échiré butter from? I thought Monmilk is banned in sg?

    July 23, 2012 at 7:45 am

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      you can get it from gourmet food shops and purveyors like Jones the Grocer and Culina. Monmilk has recently made it back onto the supermarket shelves lately after the melamine scare a couple of years back.

      July 23, 2012 at 9:52 am

  2. Ivy

    (wave!) so what is this Doux butter ??

    July 23, 2012 at 9:12 am

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      Doux means unsalted. Semi-sel is salted 🙂

      July 23, 2012 at 9:30 am

  3. This cake seem to be a hit after wendy has shared in her blog. Must try one day …

    July 23, 2012 at 10:06 am

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      oh yes! Its a wonderfully simple but flavourful cake! Now in retrospect, I’m so glad she managed to get her church mate , Mrs Ng S K to share the recipe!

      July 23, 2012 at 10:11 am

  4. Tried this before and it was good. Best eaten fresh or the next day. Somehow it dry out after the third. Maybe should have cling wrap before chilling. I left it in air tight box but I just couldn’t contain the moisture afer.

    July 23, 2012 at 11:02 am

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      oh yeah! I love how the flavours developed on the second day and yet remained really moist. The cake I baked didnt last til the third day! LOL

      July 24, 2012 at 11:14 am

  5. Hi Alan…under the hand of the pro…this method surely is good. I always feel intimidated by the method especially if the method is more or less like the chiffon cake :p But like you say..no try no gain. I must try this again ! Using a good butter is important I guess when making butter cake. It is the star for the cake 🙂 I can’t find this french brand of butter over here…guess it must be very pricey eh 🙂 Yours looks good and I am drooling and imagining the aroma of it 🙂 salivating la LOL!

    July 23, 2012 at 11:39 am

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      Not a pro la! just that Wendy’s recipe was very good! 🙂

      July 24, 2012 at 11:15 am

  6. All the good stuff in there.
    Your neigbour made the right choice when she exchanged the cupcakes with u.

    July 23, 2012 at 12:49 pm

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      hahaha well… have to share share mah!

      July 24, 2012 at 11:15 am

  7. Ok, oficially starving now, and craving this butter cake! Funny, just saw this butter today as I was doing my shopping and thought, when I run out of mine, will get this. Now I know I have a reason to get it!

    July 23, 2012 at 7:38 pm

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      ah, you could get Echire readily where you are? We have to go to gourmet food stores to get them 😦 and have to pay a premium for them too 😦

      July 24, 2012 at 11:16 am

      • Same here, but probably a little less, since France isn’t that far away!

        July 24, 2012 at 2:41 pm

      • Alan (travellingfoodies)

        I’m so jealous!!!!!!!~~~~~~

        July 24, 2012 at 3:39 pm

  8. The picture of the butter cake got me drooling! This is definitely not your average, run-of-the-mill butter cake with the use of such premium butter!

    I suppose the separation of eggs method would give a much lighter texture compared to a typical butter pound cake?

    Could you share more on your choice of Monmilk?

    July 24, 2012 at 2:16 pm

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      Hello! Yes i think the creaming/chiffon method does yield a cake with lighter textures on the whole. It makes the whole cake much more palatable, owing to much of its soft and fluffy textures.

      Using Mon Milk from Inner Mongolia is purely incidental. One of the rare occasions when the pantry was out of fresh milk and UHT (despite it being purportedly “fresh”) was used. Thankfully, it was rather creamy compared to the other UHT brands we are accustomed to seeing… 🙂

      July 26, 2012 at 9:57 pm

      • Thanks Alan for sharing! I have yet to try Mon Milk. Gotta keep a look out for it and taste the difference for myself!

        July 27, 2012 at 9:38 pm

  9. niramo pontataiyong..

    hi,pls help i don know where in sg i can the echire butter,,
    would you mind to share n let me know to get ,,tanks,,

    July 30, 2012 at 1:00 pm

  10. i hope to make this too..sure sure must get good quality butter especially making butter cakes like this…alan, me like a foreigner here, never even heard or seen those butter here!

    August 12, 2012 at 11:37 pm

  11. octopusmum

    HI Alan

    you have a v nice blog. would like to try this butter cake but i am not going to buy self raising flour for this…may i know if i use 200g plain cup, how many tsp of baking powder do i have to add ? thks v much.


    October 3, 2012 at 4:23 pm

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      thanks I added one tsp of baking powder for every 3/4 cup of flour. you can use that as a gauge for making your own self-raising flour like I did. Hope that helps!

      October 3, 2012 at 10:32 pm

  12. Regine

    Wow wow. What a soft buttery cake. Excellent recipe. I did like you and used enough of the plain cake/baking powder formula to replace the self rising flour. But i did not have an 9 inch square cake pan so i used a 9 inch springform pan. I had to bake it 30 more minutes at the 150c degree due to pan being a bit deeper. But cake was wonderful. I may buy a square pan just fot this recipe next time i make it. I may too put some lime or lemon zest next time. This is the bestest butter cake recipe ever. Thanks for sharing! It reminds me of the famous sara lee cakes one can buy in supermarkets in the US. Your cake is magically buttery yet with a soft/spongy/light texture, and it is not too sweet.

    October 31, 2012 at 11:17 am

  13. Shenny

    Aduh, if I let u run a bakery, food cost will be sky high!
    My family love this recipe so much. Most expensive ingredient for me is butter…
    Your recipe is definitely even more expensive than mine.
    Will try this premier butter cake recipe if I could find the ingredients you mentioned.

    December 11, 2012 at 11:55 pm

  14. Pingback: 微熱山丘鳳梨酥 SunnyHills Pineapple Cakes | travellingfoodies

  15. Sue

    Hi may I know where did u get the vanilla paste?

    May 28, 2014 at 9:30 am

    • Alan (travellingfoodies)

      Sorry for the late reply Sue. I must have overlooked this. Are you from Singapore? you can get it from Phoon Huat outlets or Lemon Zest at Chip Bee Gardens in Holland Village.

      October 26, 2014 at 8:47 pm

  16. Aisha khan

    Hi there! I just wanted to thank you for sharing such an amazing recipe! I also wanted to ask if it’s possible to bake this in a 9x4x3″ loaf pan? Would i need to half the batter?

    June 6, 2016 at 2:52 pm

  17. Evelyn

    Hi can I check the oven setting you used? Bake at 170C with fan or without? Thank you.

    June 15, 2019 at 4:04 pm

  18. Eve

    Hi, I do not have a 9×9 inch pan, can I use this recipe on an 8×8 inch pan? And if whether I need to reduce the recipe to suit the 8×8 pan?

    January 10, 2020 at 12:42 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s